Impossible Pie

by Gourmet Jack on March 24, 2010

Jack’s mother was a heck of a cook and was well known at the local Farmers Markets, bake sales and agricultural fairs. She would get weekly orders for her cakes, jams and chutneys. Christmas was always very busy with her small kitchen producing many Xmas puddings and Xmas fruit cakes. We got to eat some great goodies as well. She built up a collection of her recipes, including some by her mother and grandmother, and created what now looks like a bundle of five pretty ratty books.

The collected works are predominately in her handwriting with a fair share of clippings from many places going back over 60 years. The collection of books are still in the family with one of Jack’s sisters. On a visit to Australia in 2008, Jack scanned every page in those books, indexed them, and put together an interactive document. A DVD was burnt and distributed to the family. Now, the recipes are available to all the family, from Australia to New Zealand, Canada, Scotland and the United States. So, Rose’s collection lives on, and from time to time, Jack will dig into it and retrieve a gem for you to practice your culinary skills and for your foodie gastronomic pleasure.

The first from The Rose Collection is one that has always had me intrigued:

Big leap of faith here GJ Foodies. Just play along with the instructions, and you will finish up with a pie that has a definite crust, a lovely custard filling, and a rich butter-coconut topping. Get the plates ready.

The Impossible Pie

Print This Post

Ingredients

4 eggs
2 cups cold milk
¾ cup sugar
½ cup all purpose flour
¼ cup butter
dash salt
1 tsp vanilla extract
1 cup shredded coconut (sweetened or not – your choice)

STEP 1

Heat the oven to 350º
Prepare a well-greased 10" Pyrex pie dish

STEP 2

Put ALL the ingredients in blender
Blend at high speed for the count of 10
Turn off blender
Pour mixture into the prepared pie plate

STEP 3

Bake for 40 minutes

STEP 4

Cool (in dish) on wire rack

STEP 5 SERVE and ENJOY

Related Posts with Thumbnails
  • http://www.worththewhisk.com Patti at Worth The Whisk

    Jack – this recipe is PERFECT for what was in my pantry today. I threw it together in just minutes, thanks to your easy instructions, and it is baking as I write this. I’ll post a photo on my blog here in California and make sure to link directly back to you. Thanks so much for this great find.

  • Gourmet Jack

    Hi Patti, Welcome to the band of Impossible Pie converts! My Mum will be very proud of everybody trying one of her favorites. Growing up, 8 of us were constantly looking for a sweet treat, and this was it. Quick, easy, and usually all ingredients in most pantries. Thank you for the cross post. Do sign up for some regular contact from Gourmet Jack, and your Gourmet Jack Foodie Certificate.

  • Rebecca Waldman

    The Impossible Pie is fabulously wonderful. Thanks for sharing.

  • pattilondre

    Hello from California, Jack! This recipe on your site looked SO great, I made it up for myself and featured it here: http://worththewhisk.com/2010/04/14/australian-… linking back to you Down Under. Hope that is OK!

  • miri

    when you say “blender”, use mean American “mixer”, right?

  • Tricia Hiser

    My Mother made this pie for us as children and it is absolutely amazingly tasting — so good it is hard to have only have one piece! If you have not tried the “Impossible Coconut Pie,” you’re missing out on one of life’s greatest culinary delights! It so incredibly simple to make compared to its taste, it is almost unbelievable: hence, the name “impossible” pie. Do yourself and your family a favor, and make this wonderful treat — people will think it took you all day to make it, rather than one hour — it is okay to let them believe you slaved to bring them this delight!

  • Tracy

    Instead of all purpose flour I use self raising to make a more filling pie. I also use 1 cup of milk and 1 cup of cream for a bit of flavour. My impossible pie is more of a meal instead of dessert so I add ham, cheese, tomato and chives and just stir with a fork or whisk. I make this when I have no food and no money. My mum always says “If you have milk, eggs and flour, you’ve got food!”

  • Tracy

    Instead of all purpose flour I use self raising to make a more filling pie. I also use 1 cup of milk and 1 cup of cream for a bit of flavour. My impossible pie is more of a meal instead of dessert so I add ham, cheese, tomato and chives and just stir with a fork or whisk. I make this when I have no food and no money. My mum always says “If you have milk, eggs and flour, you’ve got food!”

Previous post:

Next post: